Rules of War

Editorials

Related Photos

Discussion

November 7, 2007

Trying to understand why we’re even having this conversation

By Bob Belcher The Corsicana Daily Sun Wed Nov 07, 2007, 02:03 PM CST

Let me be clear. I never served in the military. Came close in the 70’s when we had draft cards and numbers. Would have gone had I been called, but I was not.

Having laid that “disclaimer” right out in front, I still have to ask the question — Why are we debating what constitutes “torture” and what doesn’t?

I thought we had that all worked out several decades ago. Apparently, I missed something, given recent dialogue and diatribes of our leaders in D.C. over things like “waterboarding” and such.

It should be as simple as this — you either torture people or you don’t.

Bill Clinton’s statement from the “Lewinsky-Gate” days — “It depends on what your definition of ‘is’ is,” — comes to mind. Either he did, or he didn’t. We all know how that one turned out.

I have no first-hand knowledge of what happens in battle, in a war zone, in a prison camp or an interrogation room. I have heard stories from those who do have such knowledge, and I wonder if I’d be able to sleep at night, knowing some of the things they have seen and endured. These people are heroes, plain and simple.

But heroes who are soldiers are typically very good soldiers, and good soldiers follow orders, and that is where things get a little muddy for me.

As was brought to light in the horrors of the Abu Ghraib prison in Iraq, the furor over Guantanamo, and the demonstrations of “waterboarding” of late, someone in the chain of command has authorized the actions, based on some yet-to-be determined interpretation of what does or doesn’t constitute torture. And those that did authorize anything less than the treatment we ourselves expect for our war prisoners to receive have got to be out of their tree, so to speak.

In my opinion, It all comes down to leadership. Or maybe lack of leadership, or lack of oversight. Whatever the case, the American military — or the American military command to be more correct — is in serious need of some change, when there are those who allow such treatment of prisoners to occur.

Maybe the “machine” has gotten too big and complex for any one person to oversee. Maybe this same thing has been happening, war after war after war, and we’re just now getting the “nitty gritty” on it all. Or, maybe we’ve just got a bunch of “bad apples” somewhere down the chain of command who just don’t care.

None of it makes any sense to me.

What I do believe is that all of the debate and uproar over the “fallout of war” has done nothing to help with the goal of the military — to protect America from terrorists. At least I think that is what we were told we were fighting for this time.

The actions that have been allowed to take place, and apparently still taking place, have only blackened the eye of some true American heroes who don’t deserve to be belittled for what they do — serve our country with courage, honor and sense of duty.

It’s time we “kick some brass,” so to speak, and go to the root of the problem — the military leaders and commanders behind the desks half a world away from the real war and play games with peoples lives.

God bless our fighting men and women — they deserve far more out of their leadership than they are getting.

————

Bob Belcher is Managing Editor of the Daily Sun. His column appears Wednesdays and Sundays. He may be reached by e-mail at belcher@corsicanadailysun.com.

Text Only

Editorials

How ‘bout it? In the words of the late, great Ronald Reagan ...

“Well, there you go again ...”
January 29, 2008 1 Photo
Hey council! Seems like only yesterday we turned the calendar over to New Year’s Day, 2007.

It also seems like, if you blinked, you missed the 2007 experience — that’s how fast the year has flown by in my mind. Yet, we’ve made it to another Christmas and New Year week relatively unscathed, with challenges aplenty remaining in our little town.
December 25, 2007 1 Photo
Table this ... That must be some table they’ve got at the Corsicana Government Center.

And, by the time they are through with the two items that have been “bouncing” on that table of late — the proposed hiring of a bond project coordinator and new regulations regarding the sale of scrap metal — they may need to get a 55-gallon can of “Pledge” to put the polish back on.
December 19, 2007 1 Photo
Rules of War Let me be clear. I never served in the military. Came close in the 70’s when we had draft cards and numbers. Would have gone had I been called, but I was not.

Having laid that “disclaimer” right out in front, I still have to ask the question — Why are we debating what constitutes “torture” and what doesn’t?
November 7, 2007 1 Photo
Good works Every once in a while I see, read or learn about something that helps to restore my faith in humanity. For the sake of good mental health, we all need that from time to time. Even before I tell you what has bolstered my faith, let me talk for just a moment about a very important word in the English language.
November 5, 2007
Some real truth about personnel I did a column on county personnel and problems with the current system of compensation that appeared in the Daily Sun on June 29. I was criticized in a letter to the editor for not looking for the truth. I took that criticism to heart; and over the last few weeks, I searched for the truth.
July 28, 2006
President’s slip a sign of the times? Write with the learned, pronounce with the vulgar. — Benjamin Franklin
July 27, 2006 1 Photo
Commentaries worse than actual column In reply to Mr. Formby’s and Mr. Armon’s guest commentaries of March 26 and March 27, I might point out that it is our opinion page and not my opinion page. Both men were very critical of reading Mr. Narasimhan’s opinion, which did not coincide with their own. They even criticized the newspaper for printing it. I thought newspapers printed both sides of a story.
April 1, 2006
Letter to the Editor
March 25, 2006
New star to have one on his helmet? Terrell Owens might have a star on his helmet come August? What? Owens, who has had clashes with every team he has played for might come to the Cowboys after Dallas released veteran Keshawn Johnson.
March 17, 2006 1 Photo
More Editorials Headlines

Editorials

Search Results

Related Photos

Discussion

Rules of War

Trying to understand why we’re even having this conversation

Site Map

Contact Us